The number one question I get asked regarding my support of Barack Obama is, “As a Christian, how can you in good faith support a candidate who’s pro-choice?”
This is an issue I’ve wrestled with for years. I’ve always considered myself pro-life. During my teenage years there were some serious abortion battles in Idaho and my sister and I even talked my Mom into putting an “I’m Pro-Life and I Pray” sticker on our car. As I’ve examined and re-examined the abortion issue over the years, I’ve had to come to terms with the fact that, politically, the issue is not as clear-cut as I would like it to be. I now consider myself “personally pro-life” and “politically pro-choice.” Let me explain.
As much as I believe in the rights of an unborn child to have a chance at life, I have come to realize that making abortion illegal will not address the fundamental issue at stake, which is preserving the lives of as many unborn children as possible. If outlawed, women seeking abortions would turn to illegal, unsanitary, unsafe methods to get an abortion anyway, as happens currently in other countries. “In Brazil, where abortion is illegal, there are twice as many abortions as in the United States, although Brazil’s population is only half that of the United States. In Latin America, illegal abortion is the number-one killer of women between the ages 15 and 39.”[3]
As we’ve seen with both Prohibition and the drug problem in the United States, just because something is illegal doesn’t mean the unwanted behavior stops. This is not just a “third-world country” problem. For example, “Cook County Hospital in Chicago, prior to the Supreme Court’s decision legalizing abortion, admitted about 4,000 women each year for medical care following illegal abortions. After the decision, the hospital admitted fewer than five such cases a month.”[3]
One key factor in the debate over abortion is when life begins. Biblically, life begins with “the first breath.”[3] The argument that life begins at conception (endorsed by the Vatican) actually comes from the Greeks, not the Bible. Modern medical interpretation is at around 24 weeks of gestation when the baby is considered viable. This is a very personal issue and subject to great interpretation. If a point has to be chosen for legal purposes, the “viability” argument makes sense to me, which is what Roe v. Wade supports.[4]
Outlawing abortion entirely seems a poorly thought-out solution to me. A much better solution would be to greatly reducing the number of unwanted pregnancies, thereby greatly reducing the number of abortions. Barack Obama’s web site outlines that he “is an original co-sponsor of legislation to expand access to contraception, health information and preventive services to help reduce unintended pregnancies. Introduced in January 2007, the Prevention First Act will increase funding for family planning and comprehensive sex education that teaches both abstinence and safe sex methods. The Act will also end insurance discrimination against contraception, improve awareness about emergency contraception, and provide compassionate assistance to rape victims.”[5]
Senator Obama’s stance on abortion has always been consistent. In a November 7, 2007 article he stated, “One of the things that I’ve always said is that abortion is a deeply moral issue. And those who would deny that there is a moral component to it I think are wrong. The reason that I make a decision to support the choice position is not because I don’t think it’s a moral issue but because I trust women to make a prayerful decision about this issue.” As a practicing Catholic, Senator Biden was initially opposed to Roe v. Wade, but said that after his 29 years in the senate he has come to believe that Roe v. Wade is “the template which [sic] makes the most sense” legally and politically.[6]
By way of contrast, in 2005 Senator McCain stated an official pro-choice position and then changed his stance in August of 2008 when confronted with the politics of a presidential election, leaving voters unsure where he truly stands.[6] Governor Palin is so adamantly pro-life that she would not condone an abortion even if one of her daughters were raped, only if her life were in danger. As Senator Obama stated above, I would trust her to consult with her daughter and that together they would make “a prayerful decision about the issue.”
Considering the issues at stake in this election, I’ve come to realize that “pro-life” needs to mean more than just “anti-abortion.” As Brian Brandsmeier stated in a recent blog posting on Clergy for Obama, “War, euthanasia, abortion, poverty, terrorism, capital punishment, AIDS, environmental degradation, violent crime, economic injustice, aggressive foreign policy, etc. all threaten and destroy life.”[8] As such, we should look at each of the candidates in a whole “pro-life” light, not just in an “anti-abortion” light.
Taking a look at the Bible, nowhere does it specifically condemn or prohibit abortion, which was a common practice in Jesus’ day.[3] It does, however, specifically instruct us to:
- Care for the poor and sick (Matthew 25:31-46, Proverbs 31:9, and Micah 6:8 among many, many others)
- Care for God’s creation (Psalm 24:1)
- End racial divisiveness (Galatians 3:28)
- Practice peace (Isaiah 2:4 and Matthew 5:9)
I feel that voting solely based on one issue fails to take the big picture into account. Voters need to take a complete look on where Senators Obama and Biden stand on all the issues in relation to where Senator McCain and Governor Palin stand on all the issues. After extensive research and prayer, as a Christian, my choice in November is clear. Barack Obama and Joe Biden have my vote.
Mindee, Editor, Missouri
Cited references and further reading:
1. Summary of Abortion Laws Around the World – pregnantpause.org
2. Abortion in Nicaragua – Wikipedia.com
3. Abortion: A Christian Ethical Perspective by Dr. John M. Swomley
4. Roe v. Wade – Widipedia.com
5. Barack Obama’s stance on Women’s Issues – barackobama.com
6. Pro-Con.org on Abortion
7. Pro-Life, Pro-Family, Pro-Obama by Brian Brandsmeier
8. Pro-Con.org on Sarah Palin’s Positions & Statements on the Issues
9. Principles and Policies for Christian Voters: An issues guide for Christians- Sojourners.com
10. Reckless accusations of infanticide – fightthesmears.com
11. OnTheIssues.org on Barack Obama, Joe Biden, John McCain, and Sarah Palin
Like this article? Email to a friend or Receive our daily posts in your mailbox
Submit your own Daily Faith Statement